Book Review: Rejection Letters

 — A Vaccine Against Rejection

Book: Rejection Letters by Edward O’Dwyer
Published: May 2025, Truth Serum Press

Most self-help books teach you how to deal with rejection. Edward O’Dwyer’s hilarious short story collection, Rejection Letters, does something far more powerful: it inoculates you against rejection by reprogramming your emotional response to it. After reading it cover-to-cover a few times, the result wasn’t a new strategy in my mind, but a subliminal shift — a new default in my nervous system. The very concept of rejection began to trigger not dread, but laughter, even in real-life situations.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

The Book: A Satirical Vaccine for Your Emotional Immune System

Rejection Letters is a fictional collection that imagines the bluntly honest and outrageously absurd reasons poetry editors might give for rejecting submissions. O’Dwyer, an accomplished Irish poet and author from Limerick, channels his insider knowledge of the literary world into dark, witty satire.

The Neuroscience: Rewiring Through Association

My experience with this book is a textbook case of cognitive reappraisal, a core emotional regulation practice. Neuroscience shows that our brains learn through association. By repeatedly pairing a negative stimulus (a rejection letter) with a potent, positive one (genuine, helpless laughter), the book forges new neural pathways.

• Before: “Rejection” → Associated with personal failure, disappointment, and disqualification.

• After Reading: “Rejection” → Associated with the book’s fictional, pompous, and hilariously petty editors.

This process breaks the cycle of negative emotional reactions that often surround rejection. It gives your brain a funnier, healthier default setting for processing a “no.”

Why This Method Works Better Than Just Advice

Traditional advice often engages only our analytical, critical left-brain thinking. Rejection Letters bypasses intellectual defenses and engages our right brain — the center of feeling and connection — creating new, automatic narrative patterns that are far more effective for lasting change. You’re not merely told to tolerate rejection; your old narrative is replaced by vivid, funny stories that reveal how inherently ridiculous and subjective many rejections truly are.

Final Verdict & Recommendation

Edward O’Dwyer has done a great service. Rejection Letters is more than a funny book; it’s a crucial and powerful tool for building cognitive and emotional resilience against any type of rejection. It is a perfect vehicle for subliminal messages that promote psychological well-being and boost your immunity to rejection.

I wholeheartedly recommend it not just to writers and poets, but to anyone who faces judgment, critique, or the fear of “not being good enough.”